Sep 29, 2022
The Hollow Hope: Can Courts Bring About Social Change?
Posted by Gerald N. Rosenberg

The Hollow Hope: Can Courts Bring About Social Change? Best Download || [Gerald N. Rosenberg], The Hollow Hope: Can Courts Bring About Social Change?, Gerald N. Rosenberg, The Hollow Hope Can Courts Bring About Social Change Liberals have acclaimed and conservatives decried reliance on courts as tools for changes But while debate rages over whether the courts should be playing such a legislative role Gerald N Rosenberg poses a far fundamental question can courts produce political and social reform Rosenberg presents with remarkable skill an overwhelming case The Hollow Hope: Can Courts Bring About Social Change? Best Download || [Gerald N. Rosenberg] - The Hollow Hope: Can Courts Bring About Social Change?, The Hollow Hope Can Courts Bring About Social Change Liberals have acclaimed and conservatives decried reliance on courts as tools for changes But while debate rages over whether the courts should be playing such a legislative role Gerald N Rosenberg

  • Title: The Hollow Hope: Can Courts Bring About Social Change?
  • Author: Gerald N. Rosenberg
  • ISBN: 9780226727035
  • Page: 214
  • Format: Paperback
The Hollow Hope: Can Courts Bring About Social Change? Best Download || [Gerald N. Rosenberg], The Hollow Hope: Can Courts Bring About Social Change?, Gerald N. Rosenberg, The Hollow Hope Can Courts Bring About Social Change Liberals have acclaimed and conservatives decried reliance on courts as tools for changes But while debate rages over whether the courts should be playing such a legislative role Gerald N Rosenberg poses a far fundamental question can courts produce political and social reform Rosenberg presents with remarkable skill an overwhelming case

The Hollow Hope: Can Courts Bring About Social Change? Best Download || [Gerald N. Rosenberg] - The Hollow Hope: Can Courts Bring About Social Change?, The Hollow Hope Can Courts Bring About Social Change Liberals have acclaimed and conservatives decried reliance on courts as tools for changes But while debate rages over whether the courts should be playing such a legislative role Gerald N Rosenberg

Doug Clark

In The Hollow Hope, Gerald N Rosenberg s detailed and fascinating study of the Supreme Court, he attempts to answer the question of whether the Court, or any court, can be an effective instrument for social change To examine this question, Rosenberg first looks at two standard views of the Court the Constrained Court and the Dynamic Court The Constrained Court views the courts as weak, ineffective, and powerless The Dynamic Court views the courts as powerful, vigorous, and potent proponents of c [...]


Adrien

Misguided, it seems, but Rosenberg is good at stringing you along within the pseudo academic style and dredges up thought Plus what he goes over that was already widely accepted still has worth, I think It s repetitive, sure, and he uses dubious framing devices, but lays out very clearly, which is of no small value, considering the complexity of the subject matter.


Frank Stein

In this book Rosenberg makes a well argued case that the great Supreme Court cases of the 20th century, especially Brown v Board of Education and Roe v Wade, had no real substantive effect on American society.He also makes his point about the Constrained Court in other fields, including environmental law, legislative reapportionment, criminal procedure, and women s rights, but these are, he fully admits, sketchily examined The heart of the book, and certainly the most convincing part, is Rosenbe [...]


Brett

It s not often, especially as I get older, that I come across a book that radically changes the way I think about something important This is one of those few books with that kind of power.Like most of us, I grew up hearing and believing the notion that major landmark court cases were instrumental in bringing about big changes to our society The Supreme Court is viewed by partisans of all types as wielding enormous power to restructure our institutions Decisions like Brown v Board of Education a [...]


Lauren

Whew, so many pages, for so lazy an author OK, first off, I actually agree with his argument, and if I were reading the first edition of this book, I might have upped the stars to 4 But this is the second edition, which was published in 2008 The first edition was published in 1991 So much has happened on all of the subjects discussed in both editions between those two dates I know, he really wanted to make a case explaining gay marriage using his theory Fine But would it kill him to update the o [...]


Kaitlyn

I found this book to be very interesting It presented a different perspective on the role of courts and social movements The thesis of the book is that courts are not the catalyst for social change Rosenberg went though and examined this through looking at various rights battles over the past century The last section of the book examined the ongoing battle for same sex marriage and the role of the courts The book is a little long for light reading but it was very interesting It is an easy read f [...]


Alex Bloom

Comprehensive Rosenberg succeeds in persuading the reader that social change is best accomplished through means other than the Court unless particular rare conditions arise that allow for the Court to be an agent of change While the thesis feels a little simplistic at times, and theoretically inclined readers might be left wanting a little , there is no doubt that it s an impressive work.


Craig

An extremely thorough examination of the limited power of the judiciary to effect social change in civil rights and other key areas Could use a third edition to update marriage equality chapters post Obergefell.


Don

This book does an amazing job of showing the why those seeking social change should not pursue their course through the courts I took Gerry Rosenberg s class at the U of Chicago and really enjoyed his perspective This is a must read for anyone involved in policy implementation.


Charles

Incredibly important book, but it gets less and less persuasive every time I come back to it I mean, I generally agree with the argument, but the actual content here suffers a bit under the weight of the many critiques that have been made over the past few decades.


Mills College Library

340.115 R8134 2008


Lance

Great work that assesses the effectiveness of seeking social change through the courts.


Brooke

Not buying the argument that courts did do not contribute to civil rights



  • The Hollow Hope: Can Courts Bring About Social Change? Best Download || [Gerald N. Rosenberg]
    214Gerald N. Rosenberg
The Hollow Hope: Can Courts Bring About Social Change?